In a surprising turn of events, the legendary Floyd Mayweather, known for his impeccable record of 50-0, faced an unexpected defeat.

The bout took place in a private setting, away from the bright lights and roaring crowds. His opponent? None other than John Gotti III, grandson of the infamous crime boss John Gotti.

The fight culminated in the eighth round with Gotti securing a shocking victory over Mayweather.

Fans and boxing enthusiasts were quick to react, many of them voicing a common sentiment: Mayweather should have lost more matches in his illustrious career.

The debate centers on several controversial bouts that left many feeling that Floyd had benefited from favorable decisions.

One of the most discussed fights is the 2015 clash with Manny Pacquiao. Dubbed the “Fight of the Century,” it was anticipated to be one of the greatest boxing matches ever.

However, the bout left many fans underwhelmed. Pacquiao, known for his aggressive style and relentless pace, seemed to be the busier fighter, but the judges awarded Mayweather a unanimous decision victory.

Critics argue that Pacquiao’s high activity level and clean punches should have earned him the win.

Another contentious fight in Mayweather’s career was his first encounter with José Luis Castillo in 2002.

Castillo, a rugged and relentless Mexican fighter, gave Mayweather one of the toughest tests of his career.

Many observers, including some at ringside, felt Castillo had done enough to secure a victory.

Despite this, Mayweather was given the nod by the judges, leading to cries of a robbery from Castillo’s camp and fans alike.

Marcos Maidana also posed a significant challenge to Mayweather. Their first fight in 2014 was a rough and rugged affair, with Maidana’s aggressive style and relentless pressure troubling Mayweather.

Many felt that Maidana’s sheer volume of punches and tenacity warranted a win or, at the very least, a draw. Nonetheless, Mayweather walked away with a majority decision victory, further fueling the debate about his seemingly impenetrable record.

Even Shane Mosley, who faced Mayweather in 2010, had his moment. In the second round, Mosley landed two powerful right hands that visibly shook Mayweather.

Despite these moments of vulnerability, Mayweather recovered and dominated the rest of the fight. Fans, however, argue that the bout showcased moments where Mayweather was on the brink of defeat.

These examples highlight the controversy surrounding Mayweather’s undefeated record.

While his skill, defensive prowess, and boxing IQ are undeniably top-tier, fans and critics alike often ponder the what-ifs of his career.

The recent loss to John Gotti III in a private match, albeit not an official bout, adds an unexpected chapter to Mayweather’s story.

It’s a stark reminder that even the greatest can face defeat, and perhaps it lends credence to those who believe that Mayweather’s pristine record should have a few blemishes from the past.

As the debates rage on, one thing is certain: Floyd Mayweather’s legacy, whether viewed as untarnished or contentious, will continue to be a hot topic in the boxing world.